I have a wizarding dilemma- I'm split between being a Slytherin or a Hufflepuff... See, if I'm honest with myself, I fit in Slytherin best, but I think Hufflepuff is a great house and I think it would bring out the best in me and I can't decide which I want to embrace as my Hogwarts house. I know this is silly and arbitrary, but it's sort of important to me. In your opinion as a fellow Harry Potter fan, do you think it would be dishonest to say I'm a Hufflepuff or do you think it'd be better to just make the most of being a Slytherin, good and bad qualities?
Well I'm not the sorting hat, but you're lucky that the house you're debating with is Hufflepuff because you know they'll take anyone and be totally fine with it, dishonesty or not. I think Hufflepuff would be happy that you want their qualities to rub off on you. If it were the other way around (a Hufflepuff wanting to be Slytherin), I'm not sure that Slytherin would take you.